All outputs are published open access. Datasets are released for reuse under CC BY 4.0.
Learning Through Litigation: A Human Rights Case for Safeguarding Oversight of U.S. Nonprofits (2026)
This article asks who owes the people U.S. nonprofits serve protection from exploitation and abuse in U.S. law and practice, and why its breach has been recorded only after the fact, through litigation, investigation, or subpoena rather than monitoring. It measures U.S. law against the duty to protect under a treaty the United States has ratified and against comparative standards, reads the U.S. cases against two decades of humanitarian practice on protection from sexual exploitation and abuse (PSEA), and proposes a ten-indicator monitoring framework as the instrument an organizational duty to protect would require.
Cite as
Gul, S. (2026). Learning Through Litigation: A Human Rights Case for Safeguarding Oversight of U.S. Nonprofits. SSRN. https://ssrn.com/abstract=6609160
Safeguarding Without a Baseline: A Crosswalk from the IASC Six Core Principles on PSEA to United States Domestic Legal and Regulatory Anchors (2026)
Module 1 of the U.S. Nonprofit Safeguarding Crosswalk Project
This working paper maps the thirteen discrete obligations contained in the IASC Six Core Principles Relating to Sexual Exploitation and Abuse against their closest United States legal and regulatory anchors. It finds that no obligation is matched by a U.S. requirement of general application that both reaches the nonprofit sector as a class and protects the people nonprofits serve: existing coverage is confined to a single certified sub-sector, conditioned on specific federal funding, binds individuals rather than organizations, or operates only as after-the-fact liability. A seven-value gap taxonomy accompanies the crosswalk as an open dataset for reuse by other researchers.
Cite as
Gul, S. (2026). Safeguarding Without a Baseline: A Crosswalk from the IASC Six Core Principles on PSEA to United States Domestic Legal and Regulatory Anchors. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22022939
The full crosswalk: 13 obligations against anchor column A and gap columns G1–G7
Element
A
G1
G2
G3
G4
G5
G6
G7(provisional)
1.1
●
●
●
—
1.2
●
●
●
●
●†
2.1
●
●
●
●
●
—
2.2
●
●
●
●
—
3.1
●
●
●
●
●
3.2
●
●
●
not coded
4.1
●
●
●
●
●
5.1
●
●
●
●
●†
5.2
●
●
not coded
5.3
●
●
●
●
●
●†
6.1
●
●
●
●
●
●
6.2
●
●
●
●
—
6.3
●
●
●
—
Figure 2 — The full crosswalk. A = a genuine U.S. anchor exists for some defined population. G7 is provisional, based on single-coder analysis pending independent recoding; “flag” (marked †) marks cells that depend on facts not yet verified. Source: Gul (2026), Module 1, Appendix A and §7.5.
AAnchored
A genuine U.S. equivalent exists for a defined population.
G1Conditional coverage
Binds only organizations that take a particular funding stream or program.
G2Population gap
Protects a class other than the people the organization serves.
G3Sub-sector gap
Confined to a licensed, certified, or chartered sector.
G4Posture gap
Triggers only after harm is suspected, rather than requiring prevention in advance.
G5Operationalization gap
No instrument specifies the system that delivers the duty.
G6Actor gap
Binds an individual, not the organization.
G7Personnel-status gap (provisional)
Attaches to employment or licensure status, so volunteers in the same role fall outside.
Figure 3 — Seven ways U.S. coverage falls short. The seven-value gap taxonomy used throughout the crosswalk, shown against the anchored baseline (A) it is measured from. Source: Gul (2026), Safeguarding Without a Baseline, Module 1.
Washington Safeguarding Baseline 2026 (First edition, September 2026)
Empirical study · Companion to Module 1
The first random-sample study of what Washington nonprofits publicly disclose about safeguarding — 100 direct-service organizations coded on six evidence-backed indicators, with their Form 990 governance answers as the comparator. Companion to Safeguarding Without a Baseline (Module 1).
Suggested citation
Gul, S. (2026). Washington Safeguarding Baseline 2026: Public safeguarding disclosures of Washington nonprofits (First edition). The U.S. Nonprofit Safeguarding Crosswalk Project. https://pseacrosswalk.org/baseline-2026.html